Comparing Lawn Replacement Quotes
Two quotes for the same lawn can be far apart and both be fair. This is how to read them side by side.
The short answer
Put every quote on the same footing: the same area, the same work, tax in or out, and a guarantee you can read. Then compare the price per square foot.
What to check on every quote
Eleven lines. The last column is what a quote from this service states for each one.
| What to check | Why it matters | What our quote states |
|---|---|---|
| Measured area | Two quotes for different areas cannot be compared. | The area in square feet, measured by the crew. |
| Unit price or lump sum | A lump sum hides the rate until you divide it by the area. | A rate per square foot: $2.50 to $3.75+ per sq ft. |
| Tear-out and haul-away | Removing and disposing of the old lawn is a large part of the work. | Included in the rate. |
| Grading | A new lawn laid on uneven ground stays uneven. | Rough grading and final levelling, included. |
| Topsoil | New roots need soil to grow into. | Fresh topsoil delivered and spread, included. |
| The grass | Type and freshness decide how the lawn establishes. | Kentucky bluegrass, harvested fresh in Ontario. |
| Guarantee | A guarantee with no stated condition is hard to rely on. | A 7-to-14-day establishment guarantee, with its watering condition. |
| HST | Tax in on one quote and out on another skews the comparison. | Every price is shown before HST. |
| Minimum charge | It decides the price of a small lawn. | A $1,200 minimum job. |
| Insurance | An uninsured crew leaves the risk with the homeowner. | WSIB coverage and liability insurance. |
| Who does the work | You should know who will be in the yard. | One local partner crew, named on the quote. |
A price per square foot against a lump sum
Some quotes give a rate, some give one figure for the job. To compare them, turn each into the other.
To turn a lump sum into a rate, divide it by the area in square feet. To turn a rate into a total, multiply it by the area. At $2.50 per square foot, a lawn of 1,000 sq ft comes to $2,500, before HST.
Both sums need the area, so check that first. If one quote measured the lawn and another estimated it, the two totals describe different jobs. Ask each contractor what area they priced.
What a low quote can leave out
A lower figure is not a worse quote. It is worth checking that it covers the same work.
-
Disposal
The old lawn is cut out but left for you to get rid of, or disposal is billed afterwards.
-
Topsoil
The new lawn is laid straight onto whatever was under the old one.
-
Grading
The ground is raked, not graded, so the humps and low spots stay.
-
The first watering and instructions
The crew leaves once the turf is down, with nothing in writing about the next 14 days.
-
A guarantee
Nothing is said about what happens if sections fail to root.
-
Tax
The figure looks lower because HST has not been added, or has not been mentioned.
What our written quote states
Lawn replacement cost by lawn sizeThe measured area, one rate per square foot, the total before HST, and the establishment guarantee with its watering condition.
The rate covers the whole job: the old lawn torn out and hauled away, the ground graded, fresh topsoil and a new lawn laid. It arrives in writing within 24 to 48 hours, from one insured, WSIB-covered local crew.
Read next
Quote questions
All questionsWhat should a lawn replacement quote include?
The measured area, the price per square foot or the total, and what that covers: tear-out, haul-away, grading, topsoil and the new lawn. It should also say whether HST is in the figure and what the guarantee depends on.
Why do lawn replacement quotes differ so much?
Mostly because they do not cover the same work. One may leave out hauling the old lawn away, fresh topsoil or grading. Another may be a lump sum on an area nobody measured. Put each quote on the same area and the same list of work before comparing totals.
Is the lowest lawn replacement quote the right one?
Only if it covers the same job. Check what has been left out before you compare the totals, and ask what the guarantee covers. A quote that states the area, the work and the tax is easier to hold anyone to.
Get a quote you can check line by line
- Free, and in writing
- One insured, WSIB-covered crew
- A price within 24 to 48 hours
Prefer to talk it through? Call (519) 635-4645